I had a rather shocking experience on the subway this evening (don't worry, Mom, nothing dangerous happened). I was riding home on the 5 from work (a personal favorite line of mine as the trip is a little shorter), and though there were a lot of seats when I got on at 59th street, it filled up quite quickly. Once you get farther down in central Manhattan, lots of people are always piling on and off at each stop, and this time I debated grabbing a seat for the rest of my ride to Brooklyn. That is, until I saw the pregnant woman getting on at the end of a crowd of people...there would be enough of a rush for seats, I figured, so I might as well not take one that should go to her. Well, to my shock, a number of people getting on before her made a beeline for the empty seats, and this woman was just left standing there. The grad student type sitting directly in front of where she stood holding the support pole briefly woke up from his snooze, looked around, and nodded off again. The woman next to him also seemed to look at this woman, then put in her earbuds and closed her eyes. The young teenager I assumed to be her son just sat there eyeing her occasionally. At this point, I'm almost overwhelmed with how ridiculous this situation is. There are enough people on this car that all of the seats are taken, but not so many that the standing crowd is packed in; there is NO way to miss this woman. Now, I understand that a lot of times, you can
think someone might be pregnant, but not know for sure, and feel awkward offering a seat. But this was a
seriously pregnant woman; I wasn't wondering whether or not she was indeed with child, I was wondering whether she would go into labor in the subway car. I just stood there, stunned, against the back door, appalled at the behavior of my fellow seated subway riders. I'm not in any way from New York, or any place remotely close to having even a moderately-used public transportation system, but even
I know that when you are on any form of public transport--train, bus, subway, you name it--if you see an elderly individual, a pregnant woman, or anyone who is visibly strained from standing, you get your tush out of your seat before karma bites it off; this is not something you mess with. I was so close to saying something, I can't even tell you how thick the lecture was on my lips. If you know me, you likely know that I don't really have a problem telling somewhat what's what if I think they need to hear it (provided of course that they're not a professional or academic superior of mine). "Excuse me," I wanted to say--and rather loudly--"but is it not immediately obvious to the majority of you that you should be hopping up to offer this woman your seat?! Isn't this common courtesy?! Do you not hear them announce it ten times a day over the car loudspeaker?!" The only thing that kept me from doing so was an insecurity about how socially acceptable it was...there are some things that are done, and there are some things that just aren't, and before I could decide that it was just too ridiculous and embarrassing (you know, for
humanity) to let go, we were at the next station and a number of people were leaving the train and the pregnant woman headed for one of the vacated seats. Two people came from behind us at the end of the car, walked right by her, and sat down, while another woman, about to take the final seat, looked up, saw her, made a face that clearly said, "ohhhhh woah now", and gestured for the woman to take the seat, which she did gratefully.
I mean really, I thought we were at a point in this world where adults with extensive public transportation experience could be counted on to look straight at someone who clearly deserves to be sitting down more than they do and offer up their seat, but evidently I was wrong.
On a similar note, Jezebel (a personal favorite blog of mine) ran an article today that talks about the difference between 'gender' and 'gender roles' and how they operate as constructs of our society in general. There is lots of interesting commentary after the article, which you can see
here, but it really got me thinking about some of these things. I heard someone today complaining about women who rage against a double standard and then expect to be treated like princesses, never paying for their own food on dates, expecting to have money spent on them constantly, always wanting the door held, etc, essentially turning themselves into hypocrites. I've seen this, and it bothers me as well, but what really irritates me is how that behavior can color people's view of
all 'feminists'--or whatever people who dislike the gender double standard wish to call themselves, because we all know what a loaded term that can be. I've had guys say to me on
numerous occasions, almost always after some conversation about feminism or gender roles or double standards or something related, "Oh, so if some guy holds a door open for you, you're saying you don't want him to do that because that's
chivalrous and chivalry is
sexist?". My response always starts, "No, BUT," and before I can finish they're jumping on me for having said, 'no'. Because before I even finish my sentence, I must be a hypocrite, too. Here's the thing, though, the 'BUT', really matters. I don't have a problem when someone holds the door for me, but I don't want them to hold it for me because I'm a woman, I want them to hold it for me because they would hold it open for
whomever happened to be coming through a door directly behind them, and were the roles reversed, I would hold the door for them as well. Should a guy pay on a date? Well if he did the asking I think he should offer, but I can't guarantee I wouldn't insist on paying for my food in that situation, and if
I'd done the asking, I would offer to pay for the whole shebang. I don't think of things like that as 'chivalry', I think of them as
manners.
We're at an odd place right now in our society with all of this navigation of ever-changing gender roles. Between trying to fight them as a stereotype enforced by one gender upon another, and dealing with the fact that we sometimes enforce them ourselves (don't even get me started about slut-shaming), I just hope we're not headed for a social climate like that I experienced on the subway car today, where manners are mistaken for chivalry and everyone tries to avoid it, lest they earn a rebuke for being sexist; perhaps instead of limiting our 'chivalry', we can do away with the term altogether and just extend manners a little more liberally to everyone, regardless of their gender identity.